So my husband has been into the whole watch me get fucked thing for a long time. He's asked me to do it since we've been married (four years now) and I finally agreed to it.
The idea always sounded good to me but I had a lot of reservations. Such as him wanting to be with another woman which I don't want. Him getting jealous or seeing me differently afterward. He assured me none of this would happen.
We're roleplayed this fantasy for him a lot. Watched the porn. I even told him in great detail about my past hookups which got him off. So, he convinced me he'd be fine with everything. We found a guy online together who is nice and fit, well endowed, and single.
We met the guy and ended up back at our place last weekend. My husband was all excited. The other guy and I hooked up while my husband watched and touched himself. Well, the other guy was very good and I got into it. He's very orally fixated (including my booty which I love but husband doesn't do), and is a take charge kind of man. Our sexual styles were very compatible. I was very turned on by him. In fact, my husband could hear how wet I was when the other guy was fucking me.
I got lost in the sex so I didn't notice my husband leave the room. We finished up and he was gone. I found him in our bedroom waiting for us to finish. I was naked, sweaty, and had cum all over my chest. My husband looked at me and while fighting back tears said "you really enjoyed yourself didn't you." I said "of course I did, didn't you?" He said he didn't know!
I was very honest and told him I enjoyed the sex very much. He kept trying to get me to say whether or not the other guy is better than he is. Yes he is but I'm not going to say that! I tell him it's different but not better.
He's not sure if he wants to do it again. He says it was "hot as hell but difficult at the same time." OMG! He swore this type of thing wouldn't happen! Now I want to keep seeing the other guy but not if my husband is going to be like this about it! I mean, my husband sat there jerking off watching us then got butt hurt because I had an orgasm?! So aggravating! Any advice out there?