Okay so I guess that's where I should start then.
Mind you we'd been talking on/off all along but it was Christmas Eve when we found ourselves alone for a while after everything was done and cleaned up. I knew that we weren't going to be having sex at all that night, not when we were going to be up pretty early the next morning and have visitors over during the day, and I had just masturbated with her the night before when some of what we continued talking about started.
She again started telling me that I should stop fighting what turns me on and just enjoy it and she said that she feels I am tense and anxious about it at times. I told her honestly that while it really turned me on to be doing what we were, that a part of me seemed to be reluctant to let go. She looked at me and asked me if I missed fucking her like Paul does. She said it straight-up like that and asked me if I missed it and if it was worth it to me to miss it if it made me feel good. I can't remember what I said but I guess it sort of came out that in some ways I don't know if it feels okay to me to - and I guess maybe she was right in how she interpreted it - but as we talked it sort of came out that I didn't feel comfortable at times showing her how much it turned me on knowing it meant that it was less sexual contact between us. She was the one who held me and said that it wouldn't change a thing no matter what turned me on, and that's what she wanted me to really understand, that despite or in light of what turns me on, it doesn't change how she feels about me. She actually said that it would make her feel wonderful if I could ever fully open up to her and share what really turns me on and how I really feel about it. She held my hand and I remember this so clearly - she said she'd listened to me a lot over the past few years and she said to me something like "I know it really turns you on that I do things with Paul that I don't with you" and then she said it "I know you like knowing that, knowing that I enjoy sex with him an not with you". She immediately said that it wasn't how it sounded but I also knew that there was some truth in that so I asked her as clearly as I could whether that was okay with her, that she enjoyed it with him and not (as much) with me and she said yes.
I guess I must have showed how I felt because she held me tightly and said that she's felt that way for a while now, and she looked at me and said that once she felt I really wanted to be the "beta thing" as she puts it, that she let herself go with it. She told me that now, she has sex with me more because she knows "we" need it and that I need it but she also said that I should know that it is much better with Paul. She said that she never fakes it with me and I believe that, there are some feelings and sensations that can't be faked, but she also said that over time she's found herself wanting it more with him than with me.
Thing was she looked at me and said "isn't this what you wanted?" And she asked me if there was anything that I would want to be different and before I could answer she asked me "do YOU enjoy it more now and are YOU getting what you wanted is more the question?". She held my hand and she said that as long as I was turned on and enjoying it, that I should just let myself enjoy it and not worry so much about everything. I told her that I was more concerned with how things were changing between us and she said to me "so, I cum with him instead of you?" and she said "that's really all it is baby, the rest is what you and I make from it". She looked at me and asked again "how is it for you?" and she added that it certainly seems to be good - and she reminded me of how full the condoms are sometimes.
I guess she finally wore me down or got through to me because I told her that while a part of me hated it, the other parts of me - so much more - really found it arousing and fulfilling to use condoms with her. She asked me why and I told her that somehow not having her - knowing that Paul has that part of her - is something that just turns me on - as if she's keeping that from me as a secret or something that I'll only get to have at some point in the future. She asked me if it was too much with Paul and whether the weekends away skiing will be okay. She said that they are sometimes playful when they're messing around and she said "you and I used to do that too, remember" and then she added that she wants to feel like she can be free to be with him as she wants to be when we're away and that I'm not going to get all upset or moody. I told her that I will be okay but that at the end of that weekend I am so going to want her. She smiled and giggled and told me "see, that's what I want us and you to feel" and she said "when we get home I'm sure you'll have your turn".
She asked me whether I missed feeling her bare and whether I enjoyed using condoms or not. I told her honestly that it just felt good to not cum in her and that yes, I so missed feeling her bare, but at the same time, it is just more of the same - that knowing Paul has her freely is something that I want to have continue. She smiled when I said "it just feels right to me somehow". She asked me if the things she's been doing with me have been helping me and I told her honestly yes, that I am feeling more secure in things with her and that her openness has kept it incredibly sexy - including her "anatomy lessons" which made her laugh and add "well you should know what he gets to feel" which I knew was intended to turn me on and make it clear what she was emphasizing to me.
She started to steer the conversation again towards whether I enjoyed the condom play we are doing and I again told her yes. "And you like what that means, right?" among other things she asked me made me realize she still wanted me to talk more and I remember coming out and saying "yes baby, it turns me on that you take him bare" to which she answered "and not you?". Which did make me groan but I told her yes. She encouraged me to tell her more and eventually asked me what the "most intense part is" for me. I had to tell her honestly that it was when I heard and saw him and knew he was cumming in her. She let out a "mmmm" sigh for a second and asked me if that turned me on and I said yes. And again she asked me "and that you don't get to do that?" and I just said "yeah, that's part of it".
She turned to me and asked me if I've thought about next year yet and I realized what she was asking so I said to her "what do you want?" and she smiled and said "I asked you first but how you answer won't change how I feel about you". I asked her if she'd tell me honestly what she would want after I answered her and she said yes. So I said yes to continuing in 2016 with me not cumming in her. A moment later I looked at her and asked her what her answer would have been if she went first and she said "I'd have said the same as you baby, I want to enjoy this as long as we can".
Now there was more we talked about but I think that's the gist of what led up to her taking some time on Christmas morning to write up those "coupons". She later told me that she'd been thinking about giving me them but didn't want to if I didn't feel that I wanted to continue what we were doing.
For Danwcap - no - she, at least for now, says that "we" still need to have sex together, just that for the most part, it's now at her discretion and desire, these coupons she said will give me a few times that I can say when I want to have it if she's not so much in the mood or if I just need to feel her or something. She hinted that maybe I'd save the 2 bare coupons for when/if we go away someplace romantic next year.
Since then, we've talked openly about enjoying New Years Eve and again planning some kind of ceremony of sorts to mark going into 2016. I reminded her that last New Years Eve I'd cum in her and she giggled and said "well, that's not happening this year" but then added "oh, we'll have fun, just you don't get that honey". And as she said that she came up to me and said "see, that's the sort of playfulness and openness I want to have between us about this" and she took me aside and we talked and she said that she doesn't want to have to have this sex with Paul thing just be when we're in bed or in a sexy mood together, that she wants to make it something we can talk about more openly at other times. I told her that we can work at that but it may take a while!