I hope to want to continue posting here, as I've said all along, it seems to help me with understanding myself.
I can say quite clearly how we got here. We were truly honest with each other spurred a bit by the news of friends separating. We both knew we still had a bit of tension and it just felt right to clear the air.
I was honest with her and I told her that I hadn't cum in her in so long was something that profoundly turned me on to know that she wanted as well as me. It felt good to tell her things so clearly and in response she told me how incredible it made her feel to have that control and know that it turned her on as much as it had me. Our feelings inside are different - she doesn't fully understand it but accepts that I am turned on that she would want and give that intimacy to Paul and deny me. The thought that only he had truly felt and experienced and shared her sex in this way for so long only seemed to turn me on even more. For her, she could only say that it was a feeling of power and control and that knowing it turned me on made it easier for her to want it - first to satisfy me, but then, definitely to satisfy herself.
I told her that what I felt I wanted was to feel as if she was fulfilling that - and for her to share and even flaunt it. But as we talked, she asked me if it wouldn't turn me on even more to have sex with her and cum in her sometimes. The more we talked, what I realized was that I wanted her to act and do it more in some ways - to tease me that her pussy is just Pauls for now - and yes, to not know when she may want to let me share her sexually again. She asked me if it wasn't better for me when I would restrain myself in the hopes of having sex with her not knowing whether I would or not. I admitted that it was - and then even admitted that at times, when she would say no or that she had enough or was sore from Paul - that when I would masturbate to those thoughts, that it was even more intense.
But I also told her that I felt a distance between us and that as she asked me about periodically cumming in her, it suddenly seemed to make me realize that her controlling that with me - and yes, her open admission that "it's not going to be very often" that made me realize it might be what is good for us. Yes, I know others here suggested that and I admit to being a bit more closed minded than I should be.
When she spoke, it was totally about how she loves the feeling of being in control of 2 men and how incredible it made her feel to do what I'd said - to give herself sexually to another man and to learn to truly enjoy it for herself. She said that every time I would put a condom on she said she felt herself get wet knowing what we were doing. And she did say it very clearly - she loves, not just likes, but loves that I didn't cum in her for so long. I haven't told her it was 8 months but she knows it's been long enough that she said she had forgotten how it felt for me to let go in her - from how different my cock feels in her bare to how much more he cums but how much more open she feels from me. Thing was, I could tell, just as how I felt, that she felt good saying what I think she had long been keeping inside.
She also said several times that she would like to do what I'd said - to make it more real for me and play it up more with Paul and to tease me more about it but at the same time, allow me to participate with them sometimes. She asked me how I would feel if it were her who teased me more when I was there with them and she smiled and said sometimes that would be nice. I asked her what she meant and she said - literally "for example, what if I told you to stay next to me and watch while Paul fucks me?". She reminded me how he doesn't really care or want to be between us at all and that she's continued to be coaching him - she admitted to sometimes asking/telling him that she wanted me to be there with them at times. And his response was that it's okay and that he's used to it now as long as he also gets some alone time with her.
She is out getting all prettied up as Paul will be here around 4pm. I told her I would give her time with him alone and would likely bring home some pizza's and wine for us for dinner and I told her to text me when she wanted me to come home. I am actually eager to be there with them tonight and, if she's in the mood, to don a condom and take my turn with her - but at the same time, as she's already warned me, that if he's staying the night, then she will likely just want to be with him and that I can "wait or not".
I think we made a lot of breakthroughs in our talks, and I suspect, from how she's talked about it, that her "treats for me" when I will get to have her bare may be more frequent but unpredictable too.
Let me run