L was ten years younger than I when we started dating, still in college, and a target of so many guys' attention; petite, innocent, and much more than just polite to every guy that flirted with her regardless of whether she was attracted to him or not. I'd visit her on campus on weekends and the amount of guys that hit on her, even there in front of me when we were together, drove me crazy. I couldn't understand why she was so nice to all of them when it was obvious they just wanted to fuck her. She had been a virgin when we met and I had been her only lover. Had I opened Pandora's box by introducing her to sex?
She had a few 'guy friends' on campus who seemed to like making me squirm when they met us during my visits, usually at a concert or party. They'd comment on her looks and offer little innuendos that there might be much more between them than L claimed. L swore they were like 'big brothers' who helped her with projects and homework in the classes she struggled with. I was sick with jealousy at times, but L would assure me I had nothing to worry about, then want to fuck soon after. That made it okay, until the next time.
L and I had an argument one night during a small gathering of her friends in her dorm room. We were drinking, and L had tried pot for the first time. When I spoke up that I thought L wasn't the type to show off her sexuality (that she just wasn't born to be slutty), she took one of her 'guy friends', pulled him to his feet, and masturbated him in front of everyone. I wasn't just shocked, I was stunned and pinned to my spot there, speechless, horrified, embarrassed, and as I later admitted, a tiny bit excited by it. It was the beginning of my angst-driven fantasies about L fucking other guys.
After we married, I finally confessed my fantasy to L one night after a night out when we both had a bit too much to drink. We were making love in bed, and to my surprise, she found pretending I was "some other guy' exciting. She was too embarrassed to talk about it the next day, but we continued to role play with it time to time, and she seemed to be more accepting each time. Eventually she would tell me who the 'other guy' would be, who she fantasized about fucking, and the role playing leaped to a new level of sexy fun for us.
Then, one night after role playing, she asked if I was serious about letting her fuck someone else, that she had decided on a guy we met at a friend's party weeks ago if I agreed. He flirted with her as though he was certain he'd fuck her, and L was smitten with his looks and confidence. I agreed, we arranged it (he had given L his business card), and wow, my innocent little wife loved it, again and again. He's been with us for over ten years now, still her favorite lover, and a role playing friend to both of us. Her initial reaction astonished me back then, but not as much as her ability to fall into the role of hotwife so quickly and easily. When we were first married, I was certain my hotwife fantasy would never, never become reality. L has surprised me over and over ever since.