What constitutes “small”

[sharklasers]

The Million Dollar Conversation, The Money Shot......women on here prefer at least 8 inches if what we read is true. Plus concrete hard and girth. Me being very small takes me fortunately out of the equation. The heat is off!

a womans vagina is only 7" deep so anything longer is going to be a waste , its thickness girth that they need

Thickness is super important and average vagina might only be 7" deep but that assumes all positions give access to that depth and women with a rounder ass or thicker thighs definitely need a few extra inches if she wants to be completely filled from every position

 

[Custer Laststand]

Believe it or not, I’ve had my measurement wrong my whole life. I had a circumcision a few weeks ago due to a tight foreskin. Erect measurement is actually just over 5. Had no idea

In that case, your wife's judgement continues to be right. According to the source I quoted (above), the length of your erect penis is within average range.